Lower than three months after the Cavaliers traded for Donovan Mitchell, I started listening to rumors swirling round his future.
He doesn’t need to be in Cleveland. He needs to be in New York. This isn’t going to final. The Cavs will ultimately need to commerce him.
Highly effective brokers, executives from different groups, and even gamers across the league whom I spoke to all agreed. The concept of Mitchell remaining in Cleveland long run simply didn’t appear possible to anybody who really labored within the league.
That’s what makes Tuesday such a major milestone for the Cavs and town of Cleveland. The commerce for Mitchell could have been the single-biggest gamble within the historical past of the franchise. His signature on a three-year, $150 million extension this week made all of it repay.
![go-deeper](https://cdn.theathletic.com/cdn-cgi/image/width=128,height=128,fit=cover,format=auto/app/uploads/2024/07/02090136/GettyImages-2151605107-1024x683.jpg)
GO DEEPER
Donovan Mitchell agrees to 3-year contract extension
No matter what occurs from right here, the Cavs gained the Donovan Mitchell commerce. That doesn’t imply Utah misplaced. Each side could be proud of the result. However the Cavs took a far better gamble and gained.
First the disclaimers: The actual fact Mitchell signed for 2 seasons plus a participant possibility is just good enterprise. He’s eligible free of charge company now after his tenth season within the league, which can web him a bigger portion of the wage cap (35 p.c vs. 30 p.c) as a 10-year vet. By the point Mitchell reaches free company, the cap may very well be upwards of $190 million. The distinction between 30 p.c of that cap and 35 p.c is sort of important.
![The Pulse Newsletter](https://wp-media-theathletic-production.s3.us-west-2.amazonaws.com/app/in-content-modules-images/in-content-module-the-pulse-newsletter.png)
Free, every day sports activities updates direct to your inbox. Enroll
Free, every day sports activities updates direct to your inbox. Enroll
Purchase
Additionally, signing this extension doesn’t guarantee he stays in Cleveland for the size of the deal. It has turn into customary observe for guys to take the cash when it’s supplied, comparable to Kevin Durant in Brooklyn and Mitchell in Utah, after which pressure your method out later if needed. A commerce in future years is all the time potential as soon as the checks have cleared. That’s not necessary at this time.
What issues proper now could be that Mitchell’s signing permits the Cavs to breathe a bit. After I first posed the query to 1 high-ranking Cavs official shortly after Mitchell arrived, about his needs to be in New York, the response wasn’t that such discuss was absurd. It was that the Cavs knew the dangers after they made the commerce. And so they pushed all in anyway.
Donovan Mitchell on Instagram:
“I’m glad I bought this sh*t finished, Cleveland.” pic.twitter.com/P7wNNZok6h
— Nick Pedone (@NickPedone12) July 2, 2024
Koby Altman took a large danger with this commerce. The Cavs’ trajectory could have been a yr early for such a daring transfer, however it’s unimaginable to foretell when stars are going to turn into out there. Bradley Beal was the star on the transfer final season. Who would you slightly have? Mitchell or Beal? It isn’t even shut.
Mitchell’s age, place and ability set match completely with what the Cavs wanted. In order that they swallowed laborious, pushed all in for Mitchell and trusted that their tradition and two years was sufficient time to persuade him to remain.
Had Mitchell advised them this summer season he wasn’t enthusiastic about an extension, it may have been disastrous. Positive, the Cavs would’ve recouped some belongings in a Mitchell commerce. However a Mitchell commerce out of Cleveland would’ve meant the Cavs surrendered the subsequent 5 years of management of their draft for a participant now not right here. One rival government, earlier than this yr’s commerce deadline, described it as a wrecking ball headed towards the Cavs in the event that they didn’t get an extension out of him. It’s the kind of danger that get guys fired.
As a substitute, Altman and the Cavs withstood two years of hypothesis and held agency of their beliefs they may get Mitchell to remain.
![go-deeper](https://cdn.theathletic.com/cdn-cgi/image/width=128,height=128,fit=cover,format=auto/app/uploads/2024/05/14084942/AP24135004417159-1024x683.jpeg)
GO DEEPER
LeBron James, Donovan Mitchell and the Cavaliers’ previous, current and future
The Knicks took themselves out of the race when Jalen Brunson emerged as a star and so they pivoted to make use of their commerce belongings to accumulate OG Anunoby. Brooklyn is a multitude and rebuilding, eliminating each New York groups.
Who else may give Mitchell a greater likelihood to win? By the point the Cavs eradicated Orlando and superior to the second spherical, the Cavs may formally level to progress. They had been a first-round playoff staff final yr and a convention semifinalist now. The arrow was pointing up.
Mitchell has fairness right here. He will get a seat on the desk. He had a vote within the dismissal of J.B. Bickerstaff and he gave his blessing on Kenny Atkinson. He’ll probably have a voice in future personnel choices. It’s the worth of doing enterprise for small-market groups just like the Cavs.
Moreover, Mitchell’s signing continues a pattern of the Cavs convincing gamers to return to (or keep) in Cleveland. For 15 years, all of the discuss has been about how free brokers gained’t come right here and stars gained’t keep.
Nicely, Max Strus just isn’t an NBA celebrity, however his signing final summer season felt important. He was an affect free agent available on the market final summer season with a number of gives. He selected to return right here. Now Mitchell has adopted that up with probably the most important signing but.
LeBron James had private causes for coming again in 2014. Mitchell selected to remain as a result of he’s snug right here and the roster gives him the perfect likelihood to contend.
The brand new collective bargaining settlement is meant to forestall tremendous groups from forming within the league’s most fascinating markets. Parity is the league’s thirty first franchise, and Mitchell’s presence retains the Cavs in rivalry for the foreseeable future.
It’s a win for Mitchell. It’s a win for the Cavs. Most significantly, no person gained greater than town of Cleveland.
(Picture: Jason Miller / Getty Pictures)