Earlier than we head into the ultimate two-week worldwide break of 2024, the European soccer weekend gave us loads to speak about! For the primary time in his teaching profession, Pep Guardiola has misplaced 4 straight video games in all competitions: what does that say about Manchester Metropolis? We additionally acquired an emphatic Actual Madrid bounce-back win, albeit one which appears like a loss given the intense harm suffered by defender Éder Militão.
Plus, there’s loads to write down with regards to Bayern Munich (who seemed higher than their 1-0 win over St. Pauli suggests), Liverpool (who gained once more), Borussia Dortmund (who damage themselves in defeat to Mainz), Man United (who stated goodbye to interim boss Ruud van Nistelrooy with a victory) and Roma (who fired their third supervisor of 2024).
It is Monday, and right here is Gab Marcotti reacting to the largest moments on the earth of soccer.
It took him practically 16 seasons and 940 video games, however Pep Guardiola has lastly misplaced 4 straight video games. What does it imply?
As I see it, the 4 defeats in and of themselves do not imply that a lot. Shedding to Tottenham was within the League Cup and sure, each groups performed a bunch of normal starters, however Erling Haaland traveled and was an unused sub. Bournemouth was a nasty defeat and a nasty efficiency. Sure, they misplaced 4-1 at Sporting, however they might simply have scored three within the first half alone. As for Saturday towards Brighton? Once more, there was doubtlessly a hat trick for Haaland within the first half, and a collapse at each ends late on: defensive errors on the again and 0.29 second-half xG.
In different phrases, Metropolis weren’t nice in any of those 4 video games, however not less than two of them might very effectively have gone the opposite approach as a result of particular person superstars can paper over collective cracks. Then, we would not be having this dialog. That is why efficiency issues greater than leads to assessing a workforce and their prospects, and the truth is that for a lot of the yr, Metropolis have been a number of notches under the usual they set in years previous.
Editor’s Picks
2 Associated
After 11 league video games and 4 Champions League outings final season, that they had conceded 11 objectives. This yr, they’re as much as 17. You’ll be able to’t assist however level fingers on the defence, particularly since his determination to play with 4 de facto center-backs is calculated to offer his entrance males extra freedom to function.
All people has heard the Rodri stats and sure, his absence looms very giant. However let’s not overstate it both. It isn’t as if Rodri goes out and he is changed by site visitors cones. Mateo Kovacic, Rico Lewis and Ilkay Gündogan are high quality footballers. There is a scheme wherein they’ll do a greater job of filling Rodri’s footwear, and Guardiola hasn’t discovered it but.
Additional up the pitch, accidents have performed a component too. Phil Foden, the league’s Participant of the Yr final season, has began lower than half Metropolis’s 15 league and Champions League video games. Kevin De Bruyne and Jack Grealish, the £100m man, simply 5; Jérémy Doku, simply six. Oskar Bobb, who is probably not a celebrity, however not less than might need eaten up some minutes, has been out all yr. And so it feels just like the burden falls on the same old shoulders: Bernardo Silva, who’s now 30, and Haaland, who has performed 96.8% of Metropolis’s league and European minutes this season.
The upshot is a Metropolis facet that, particularly not too long ago, has seemed extra jaded, much less sharp and fewer intense. And one which has endured second-half collapses.
Haaland himself is one other problem. He is scoring a objective a recreation this season and no one goes to argue with that. However we’re additionally accustomed to him overachieving his xG, as a result of that is what superstars do, solely this yr, he is slightly below that.
Extra broadly, it appears like the tip of a cycle. Sporting director Txiki Begiristain is leaving in June. Till he indicators a brand new deal — and to this point, he hasn’t wished to commit — so too will Guardiola. There’s the 115 fees hanging over the membership: we do not know the way they will go, however the worst case state of affairs (from a Metropolis perspective) is terrifying. The summer season switch window introduced Savinho (from one other Metropolis Soccer Group membership) and the return of Gundogan (for one yr, on a free, at 34): hardly the stuff of long-term planning, which, given the circumstances, is comprehensible.
All this will engender a way of drift, and it is precisely what Guardiola must stave off as a result of the story of Metropolis’s 2024-25 season has but to be written. Metropolis are second within the Premier League. They’re two factors out of the highest eight within the Champions League and, as soon as they’re within the knockouts, no one will need to face them. After the break, it is Tottenham at dwelling and, particularly, Liverpool away on Dec. 1. That is when you’ll be able to reboot your season.
Éder Militão’s harm overshadows Actual Madrid’s bounce-back win
Actual Madrid took out all their frustration following defeats within the Clasico to Barcelona and the Champions League to Milan with a complete 4-0 win over Osasuna.
Vinicius Jr. introduced his seasonal objective complete to 12 and reminded you why he is at all times price having round, regardless of what the urgent/analytics nerds say. Jude Bellingham additionally scored and Madridristas will hope it jump-starts his season. It is simple to be essential of the strutting, and he hasn’t been close to final season’s degree. It is also price reminding ourselves that he solely turned 21 in the summertime and in contrast to final yr, when he performed within the gap with the workforce revolving round him, this yr he is being shuffled across the pitch in Carlo Ancelotti’s search of steadiness.
STREAM ESPN FC DAILY ON ESPN+
Dan Thomas is joined by Craig Burley, Shaka Hislop and others to convey you the newest highlights and debate the largest storylines. Stream on ESPN+ (U.S. solely).
All of this, nevertheless, is overshadowed by Éder Militão’s ACL harm, coming simply seven months after his return from the earlier one. There’s a person dimension to this — firstly, you are feeling for the man — and there is a real-world affect on the workforce too. With Rodrigo and Lucas Vázquez struggling lesser accidents (plus Dani Carvajal and David Alaba already sidelined), Ancelotti ended the sport with a again 4 of Fede Valverde, Antonio Rüdiger, Raúl Asencio and Fran García. Raul who? Yeah, this man.
It is evident Actual Madrid want to return into the switch market in January. Going into the season with Rudiger and Eder Militao as the one match senior central defenders was already a stretch. (Alaba is predicted to return later this month, however who is aware of what situation he’ll be in.) That half is non-negotiable, as a result of the one different choices listed here are the aforementioned Asencio and Jesús Vallejo, who has began 5 video games in 4 years and appears like a man counting down the times to free company. They’re going to additionally want cowl at right-back and a passer in midfield, which is why I nonetheless like my Joshua Kimmich concept, however clearly that is subordinate to dwell our bodies on the pitch.
Oh, and for these holding rating at dwelling, sure, Thibaut Courtois and Aurélien Tchouaméni are additionally injured (although hopefully they will be again after the break or shortly thereafter).
Antonio Conte rages, however Napoli get an excellent level away to Inter to remain high of Serie A
Truly, the Napoli supervisor wasn’t raging concerning the recreation, however concerning the penalty awarded to Inter, which Hakan Çalhanoğlu smacked towards the submit — his first missed spot kick in Serie A after changing 19 straight. Çalhanoğlu’s mistake meant it had no affect on the sport, nevertheless it did elevate a philosophical VAR-related level: there was contact between Franck Zambo-Anguissa and Denzel Dumfries as the previous tried to protect the ball, however to Conte (and me) it appeared incidental and definitely not sufficient to be a foul.
STREAM ESPN FC DAILY ON ESPN+
Dan Thomas is joined by Craig Burley, Shaka Hislop and others to convey you the newest highlights and debate the largest storylines. Stream on ESPN+ (U.S. solely).
The referee, who was close by, gave it and VAR didn’t order an on-field overview. Why? As a result of the match official noticed it clearly, as a result of it wasn’t a transparent and apparent mistake and since in Serie A and elsewhere, one of many tips given to VAR officers is that if the referee has a transparent view, you must solely intervene primarily based on whether or not contact exists, not on the character or severity of the contact. The rule of thumb exists to keep away from countless re-refereeing and since, as we have all heard earlier than, issues look worse in gradual movement replays.
I feel most of us would agree the penalty should not have been given. Whether or not VAR ought to have intervened or not is a distinct matter and it comes down as to if you need to reduce it or see expertise used as usually as potential.
I can see each side. In an ideal world, there can be belief and chemistry between the VAR and the referee and the VAR would say: “Hey, that contact seemed kinda gentle to me … are you assured in your determination?” And the referee would belief the VAR sufficient to say sure or no. However hey, the world is an imperfect place.
As for the sport itself, Napoli arrange very effectively. Take the penalty out of the combination and Inter’s anticipated objectives have been 0.76 — they have been solely overwhelmed by a Çalhanoğlu worldie. Napoli did not produce a lot on the attacking finish (simply two photographs heading in the right direction), however they did not have to. Simone Inzaghi served up one thing totally different — when is the final time you noticed him make his first sub with solely eight minutes to go? — however with Lautaro Martínez having an off day, it was at all times going to be a wrestle.
Why Chelsea will probably be happier with Sunday’s 1-1 draw than Arsenal
Mikel Arteta was decidedly extra grumpy after Arsenal’s 1-1 draw at Stamford Bridge, presumably due to the late likelihood that ought to have fallen to Kai Havertz (however that Leandro Trossard one way or the other took). Recency bias is barely human, in spite of everything, and Arsenal might have used the three factors, which is why after the sport he talked about his workforce needing to “naked their tooth” and stepping up when “it will get darkish and tough.”
It is a bit excessive — to not point out it is unclear how a lot of an impact it is going to have heading into a global break. Declan Rice performed with a damaged toe, Bukayo Saka did not look notably match both and Havertz ran round with a bandaged head. This does not really feel like a workforce that is “mushy.”
2:05
What aren’t Arsenal displaying the type of title contenders?
Janusz Michallik breaks down Arsenal’s points as they fall 9 factors behind Liverpool on the high of the Premier League desk.
In reality, for Arsenal this was extra of a “cannot lose” than a “should win.” Defeat would have meant three losses on the spin in all competitions and dropping right down to seventh place alongside Fulham (no disrespect). The draw — and Martin Odegaard’s return from harm — means you are third and with a distinct narrative heading into the break.
As for Chelsea, they’re additionally third, albeit with the locations behind the highest two so tight proper now, they might additionally discover themselves tenth after the subsequent spherical. (So, too, might Arsenal.) Extra telling, maybe, is that they’ve 4 factors greater than on the similar stage final season and so they look extra cohesive. On a day when Nico Jackson and Cole Palmer have been each subdued, they held their very own towards Arsenal, who’re a lot additional alongside of their growth.
Fast hits
10. Jamal Musiala shines as Bayern hardly break a sweat in St. Pauli win: Yeah, supervisor Vincent Kompany described it as “difficult”, their xG was simply 0.80 and so they gained by a single objective, a stunning effort from Musiala. However then, Bayern conceded simply three photographs (none heading in the right direction) for an xG of 0.08, with each Harry Kane and Musiala lacking gilded probabilities. It wasn’t domination; it was management. That should not be a priority. If you are going to discover fault, do it with Leon Goretzka, who had little affect in his first begin of the season, or Leroy Sané (additionally in his first begin), who provided even much less aside from two unbelievable lengthy vary hit-and-hopes. Unsure how usually we’ll see these two once more within the beginning lineup.
2:15
Nicol: Arne Slot’s tactical modifications have Liverpool dreaming of a title
Steve Nicol says Liverpool’s return to an attacking type of play has eased his doubts surrounding Arne Slot’s imaginative and prescient for the workforce.
9. Liverpool aren’t excellent, however they’re powerful and ruthless with room to develop: Saturday’s 2-0 win over Aston Villa was removed from routine, however a bit just like the resounding Bayer Leverkusen victory in midweek (with the guests’ line of three defensive midfielders), it proved Arne Slot might overcome a savvy supervisor tailoring his set-up to cease the Reds … and failing. Villa truly had solely a pair photographs lower than Liverpool and based on OPTA, they created extra “huge probabilities.” Villa boss Unai Emery wouldn’t have been displeased at how issues have been panning out on the pitch and but, Liverpool hung in there, turning two Villa attacking corners into devastating counterattacks, transformed by Darwin Núñez and Mohamed Salah, and that was that. By some means, they by no means actually seemed flustered. It appears like they’ll get even higher, too. Alexis Mac Allister just isn’t but on final season’s degree and the chemistry within the attacking third can enhance too. On the flip facet, Ryan Gravenberch has performed each minute of each league and Champions League recreation this season. He is finished it very effectively and in a wholly new function. Can he maintain this degree? If he goes down, can Slot discover a resolution? Judging by how resourceful their new supervisor has been, you would not guess towards it.
8. Koopmeiners pulls his weight as Juve win derby: Tim Weah and Kenan Yildiz will get the headlines (particularly the latter together with his ode to Ale Del Piero’s fiftieth birthday celebration), nevertheless it’s onerous to overstate the affect Teun Koopmeiners had on this recreation. The Dutchman was their huge summer season signing (from Atalanta) and whereas there’s extra to return, he provides Juve calm, high quality and physicality. The inconsistency that has marked all of them season lengthy? There’s much less of it when he is on the pitch. Juventus took the lead, battered Torino within the first half (limiting them to 0.02 xG) after which managed the lead after the break, whereas including the second objective: identical to grown-up groups are purported to do.
1:01
Michallik: Van Nistelrooy gave Man United a ‘inexperienced gentle’ to assault once more
Janusz Michallik appears again on a 3-0 win for Manchester United over Leicester Metropolis to shut out Ruud van Nistelrooy’s time as interim supervisor.
7. Ruud van Nistelrooy says goodbye with a win, and Alejandro Garnacho is grumpy: Two totally different feelings have been on present at Outdated Trafford this weekend. First, interim supervisor Van Nistelrooy leaves with humility and together with his resume considerably burnished. His stint felt Hippocratic in nature: “Above all, do no hurt,” and he did not: he tightened issues up and let the truth that United have higher gamers than most of their opponents make the distinction. Let Ruben Amorim do the heavy carry of philosophy and ways and being the Messiah. Garnacho got here on as an alternative and scored an incredible objective, however didn’t have a good time. In keeping with Bruno Fernandes, he was irritated on the criticism he acquired from a few of the Outdated Trafford crowd. It is bizarre to see, however to me it isn’t an enormous deal. He is not paid to have a good time; he is paid to carry out and if appearing like this helps him channel his feelings, go forward. It isn’t disrespectful to the followers although in the long term, the “chip-on-your-shoulder” schtick will get just a little previous.
6. Xabi Alonso is not a one-season marvel, however how he bounces again will say quite a bit about him: This weekend’s draw towards Bochum and newly put in coach Dieter Hecking makes it one win in eight league and Champions League video games for Xabi Alonso and Bayer Leverkusen. Approaching the heels of the 4-0 spanking at Anfield, this efficiency was arguably worse. Bochum had one level and 9 eight defeats going into this recreation. Their equalizer got here later, nevertheless it was not undeserved, as evidenced by the xG (0.51 to 0.61) and the truth that they outshot the defending champions. A livid Lukas Hradecky stated it “felt like a defeat,” whereas Xabi Alonso stated he felt “a way of deja vu.” Final yr, the whole lot went their approach. This season is a sterner take a look at, as a result of coaches may have intervals like this, when little works. He can embrace this example since you usually study extra in adversity than in intervals the place you get all of the breaks. The various golf equipment who’re monitoring him will study extra about him, too.
5. Fonseca’s recreation of whack-a-mole continues as Milan held as Cagliari: It was arrange properly. Journey the momentum of the Actual Madrid win into victory away to Cagliari, who have been coming off three straight defeats. Give the 16-year-old phenom Francesco Camarda his first begin instead of the unavailable Álvaro Morata and, now that he was off the naughty step, unleash Rafael Leão. The latter two got here to fruition (Leao scored twice and was, at instances, unplayable: his return to the fold is a serious coup… if it lasts). The primary didn’t, as Milan paid a hefty worth for poor defending and particular person errors (like Youssouf Fofana’s again go). And now, simply as he will get to grip with the assault (3.20 xG on the street is quite a bit), he has one other riddle to unravel: tightening up a again line that out of the blue appears leaky.
4. Roberto De Zerbi may be very near leaping the shark: His model of soccer is enjoyable to observe and efficient and in his early Brighton days, he got here throughout as passionate, however humble. With Pep Guardiola’s endorsement he seemed like a rising star within the teaching ranks. He is nonetheless a massively gifted coach, however he could need to work on his PR. The sulky approach issues ended at Brighton — not a membership the place coaches usually fall out — did him no favours, however he is taken it up a notch at Marseille. L’Equipe reported that upon arriving on the membership, he confirmed his gamers a photograph of a contract supply he acquired from Manchester United, one he turned right down to work with them as an alternative. And after shedding at dwelling to Auxerre, 3-1, he stated: “If I am the issue, I am prepared to depart. I am going to depart the cash and hand again my contract.” Here is the factor. A-list golf equipment, like those he presumably desires to handle in the future, usually do not prefer it once you make confidential contract provides public; they prefer it even much less once you throw hissy matches and threaten to give up in post-game press conferences. Marseille are third in Ligue 1 and with no European soccer, he has loads of time to work and chase Paris Saint-Germain. Get on with that and the whole lot will probably be effective. However if you happen to act unhinged, you will not be serving to your self.
1:21
Flick insists VAR made the ‘mistaken determination’ after Lewandowski offside
Hansi Flick reacts to the VAR controversy in Barcelona’s 1-0 loss to Actual Sociedad in LaLiga.
3. Belief your eyes, or belief the machines? Unpacking Barcelona’s loss at Actual Sociedad: With out Lamine Yamal, Barcelona seemed flat away to Actual Sociedad, which is greater than comprehensible. Many of the starters have performed a ton of soccer to this point, and la Actual deserve a ton of credit score, each defensively and in transition, as evidenced by the quantity (2.02 xG to 0.64, 14 to 11 within the shot rely and Barca with zero photographs heading in the right direction). However the recreation was additionally notable for Robert Lewandowski’s objective that was struck off by VAR for offside. In actual time — and on the video replay — Lewandowski’s foot seems to be forward of Nayef Aguerd, however within the semi-automatic offside recreation, you simply form of see a black mass of ft. Given the positioning of the gamers’ limbs, it appears as if Lewandowski would want to have huge ft to be past Aguerd. Both that or he was enjoying in clown footwear. Perhaps it is the digicam angles, who is aware of? The odd factor is many people have come to have blind religion in semi-automatic offside, however machines have margins for error too. Incidents like this sow doubt.
2. Emre Can’s unhealthy determination modified the sport, however Dortmund’s horror present not simply right down to him: Positive, you’ll be able to’t have your veteran captain stand-in center-back getting despatched off 27 minutes into the sport. That is apparent. However, with Niklas Süle and Waldemar Anton unavailable, Nuri Sahin compounded issues by dropping Felix Nmecha — who had by no means performed there — into the again 4, relatively than trusting one of many younger defenders he had on the bench. Nmecha was chargeable for two of Mainz’s objectives within the 3-1 defeat, however greater than that, he was put underneath stress by the overall futility of the entrance males, who managed only one shot from open play regardless of having the majority of the possession. No matter optimism was generated by their win over Leipzig is dissipating rapidly.
1. Not a lot in the best way of clear-eyed pondering at Roma as Juric will get the boot too: A 3-2 defeat at dwelling to Bologna price Ivan Juric his job this weekend after simply 53 days (and 12 video games) in cost. The writing was on the wall, although with this possession, you marvel if a powerful win would have modified the Friedkins’ minds. The checklist of potential successors runs the gamut from Roberto Mancini (recent off his sacking by Saudi Arabia, although his Lazio previous would make it really feel bizarre) to Claudio Ranieri (Roma-born and bred, however the man is 73 years previous) to options overseas like Edin Terzic and Frank Lampard. Roma stated the search has been underway for the previous few days, although you marvel who’s doing the looking given the membership don’t have any chief government since Lina Souloukou give up in September and a director of soccer, Florent Ghisolfi, who speaks no Italian and no one appears to love (or hearken to). What ought to infuriate followers most although — aside from the fixed hiring and firing — is the dearth of path. In 2024 alone, the membership has gone from Jose Mourinho to Daniele De Rossi to Ivan Juric: three completely totally different profiles who’ve completely totally different approaches to the sport of soccer. And now, another poor soul will are available, presumably getting in one other path fully.
