The Player Welfare Debate: Is Football Really at a Breaking Point?

Barcelona defender Jules Koundé has since come out in assist of Rodri.

“Yearly we’ve got extra video games and fewer relaxation,” he mentioned final month. “We gamers have been saying this for 3 or 4 years, however no person pays consideration to us. The time will come once we should go on strike to make ourselves heard, as Rodri mentioned.”

Arsenal’s Jurriën Timber has adopted go well with, insisting “we’re shut” to motion from the gamers if nothing have been to be achieved to handle the difficulty. Metropolis’s Bernardo Silva is one other to have weighed in, calling the schedule “absurd” and “utterly loopy”.

The chief government of the Skilled Footballers’ Affiliation (PFA), Maheta Molango, has additionally referred to as for stricter measures on the subject of what number of video games elite gamers must be allowed to play in a given interval. He has additionally insisted he would assist any strike ought to the gamers determine direct motion was essential.

So, whether or not the game is at breaking level or not, we’re at a stage the place the gamers’ willingness to proceed as they’re is in severe query, and adjustments might due to this fact be essential.

However trying again by means of our data, the stats counsel this isn’t essentially the most excessive the footballing calendar has ever been.

Sure, we’ve obtained extra Champions League video games within the new-look league part plus an additional play-off spherical, and there’s now the Convention League in addition to the Europa League. There’s subsequent summer season’s Membership World Cup, whereas the European Championship and World Cup tournaments have been expanded, and the introduction of the Nations League has additional elevated the variety of worldwide matches being performed in Europe.

However it’s additionally true that concessions have been made elsewhere. 20 years in the past, the English prime flight was decreased from 22 groups to twenty, and shortly after that English groups competing in Europe have been granted a bye to the third spherical of the League Cup. League Cup replays have been scrapped after which, in more moderen occasions, FA Cup replays adopted, whereas extra-time has additionally been faraway from the League Cup till the semi-finals.

There may be potential for Metropolis’s home and European marketing campaign to final 68 video games in 2024-25, from the Neighborhood Defend on 10 August 2024 to the Champions League remaining on 31 Could 2025. And that’s not even bearing in mind the Membership World Cup, consisting of no less than three extra video games and as much as a most of seven, which is able to start simply 16 days afterward 15 June and finish on 13 July, round a month earlier than 2025-26 begins. On prime of that, the Premier League has, in line with Metropolis supervisor Pep Guardiola, refused the champions’ request to delay their begin to the brand new home marketing campaign after competing within the CWC.

The relentlessness of that potential schedule is what considerations many individuals, but it surely additionally must be famous that it’s the exception and never the rule; the very best groups on the planet are in a singular place of directly having the ability to compete on each entrance and being the very best outfitted to take action by way of sources.

And the reality is that Metropolis’s season most likely gained’t final so long as 68 video games earlier than they get to the Membership World Cup. They’re unlikely to wish the two-legged play-off spherical to make it by means of the league part of the Champions League, whereas Guardiola has already insisted his group is not going to “waste power on” the League Cup. Most groups will play nothing like 60 video games, not to mention 68.

Final season, Metropolis performed 59 matches in all competitions, which was greater than every other group in Europe’s prime six leagues. Competitions just like the Convention League imply sides like Aston Villa (56) and Fiorentina (58) weren’t far behind, however most groups in these leagues performed fewer than 50 matches. 5 Premier League groups performed as few as 42 video games, and 36 sides throughout these six divisions performed fewer than 40. For a lot of Europe, there isn’t a challenge with gamers dealing with too many matches.

There are exceptions, although, and there all the time have been.

Within the historical past of top-flight English soccer, there have been 13 examples of a group enjoying 65 or extra video games in a season. Solely two of these, nonetheless, have come because the flip of the century: Manchester United in 2008-09 (66) and Chelsea in 2012-13 (69).

In that Chelsea season, Juan Mata performed a whopping 64 matches, beginning 55 occasions and enjoying a complete of 4,920 minutes. He additionally got here into the season on the again of serving to Spain to win Euro 2012 and – fairly extremely – beginning all three of Spain’s video games on the London 2012 Olympics.

As soon as the season was over, Chelsea went on a post-season tour to the USA, the place they performed two money-spinning friendlies towards Manchester Metropolis. Mata then flew to Brazil to assist Spain to a runners-up medal within the 2013 Confederations Cup, the place he performed in 4 of a doable 5 video games.

The Spaniard turned a legend over his time at Stamford Bridge, cherished extra for his creativity and disarming cheeky smile than his sturdiness, however his profession took an sudden downturn shortly after that marathon marketing campaign. Chelsea offered him to Manchester United halfway by means of the next season (2014-15). He by no means once more hit the heights he had at Chelsea.

Mata solely managed greater than 4,000 minutes as soon as extra in his profession – in 2015-16 with United – and after turning 28 in the direction of the tip of that season, his affect on the prime of the sport waned. He turned more and more peripheral at Outdated Trafford, enjoying much less and offering fewer and fewer telling moments in large video games. Taking a look at how his enjoying time dwindled within the years that adopted, it’s pure to surprise if that taxing 2012-13 had performed an element. Had enjoying a lot soccer in a brief house of time caught up on a participant not significantly recognized for his bodily capabilities?

In the meantime, two top-flight groups in English soccer historical past have performed much more video games than Chelsea did in 2012-13 – Stoke Metropolis in 1971-72 and Arsenal in 1979-80. Each performed 70 matches.

For Stoke, their schedule was packed as a consequence of enjoying in an enormous number of competitions. In addition to enjoying within the previous First Division (during which they, bizarrely, completed seventeenth) additionally they gained the League Cup, progressed to the semi-finals of the FA Cup, and competed within the Anglo-Italian Cup and the Texaco Cup.

Arsenal, in the meantime, performed 11 video games on their approach to the FA Cup remaining in 1979-80, together with 4 matches (three replays) within the semi-final towards Liverpool, and in addition went all the best way to the UEFA Cup Winners’ Cup remaining. Additionally they, pretty ridiculously, performed seven matches within the League Cup though they solely entered within the second spherical and have been knocked out within the fifth.

These have been days lengthy earlier than nine-player benches and 5 adjustments being permitted. Just one substitute was allowed, and plenty of managers didn’t change their groups fairly often. In consequence, Stoke’s Jackie Marsh performed 69 video games in 1971-72. For Arsenal, it was that season during which Brian Talbot began all 70 matches.

“It was actually an fulfilling time,” Talbot tells us. “I used to be lucky to be younger, match and wholesome, and I wished to play each week.

“The partitions of my coronary heart are thicker than regular – that was one thing I used to be born with. Once I was enjoying, I had a resting coronary heart charge of 39; that’s a marathon-runner’s coronary heart charge. I wasn’t a marathon runner, but it surely helped me play a lot.”

Cup replays and a European journey clogged up Arsenal’s schedule. The fixture listing obtained so crowded late within the season that Arsenal have been pressured to play three video games within the house of 5 days. The second of these video games was an away north London derby that Arsenal requested to be moved, however Spurs refused. The Gunners went to their rivals and gained 2-1, with momentum maybe a much bigger issue at that stage of the marketing campaign than fatigue. There was no break for gamers like Talbot, however was enjoying so relentlessly for the very best?

“I assumed it was a incredible concept,” he says. “When you had a knock again then, you’d play by means of it. I wished to play each single recreation. Generally it was tough, however you simply obtained by means of it.”

Issues did certainly get very tough for Arsenal later within the season, the gruelling schedule showing to get the higher of them. They fell away within the league regardless of not coaching for the final two months of the season, ultimately lacking out on European qualification and shedding each cup finals. It was after a defeat to West Ham within the FA Cup remaining at Wembley that Talbot handed out on the group bus, 4 days earlier than beginning the Cup Winners’ Cup remaining. It’s a sequence of occasions that absolutely wouldn’t play out within the trendy recreation.

“On the time, I assumed it was completely the appropriate determination, and I nonetheless assume so,” Talbot says. “I’ve by no means suffered any ailing results. I began my enjoying profession at 15 with Ipswich and performed on till I used to be 38. Even now, I’m 71, and I’m nonetheless going out operating, although I’m nonetheless no marathon runner.”

Trying on the common variety of video games performed by English top-flight groups in every season, we are able to see that the Nineteen Seventies, Eighties and early Nineties introduced the height – at greater than 50 video games per group and the odd season pushing 55.

However the basic development within the variety of video games being performed because the introduction of the Premier League within the early Nineties – and the numerous aforementioned measures to create gaps within the schedule – is downwards. For the reason that division was decreased from 22 to twenty groups forward of the 1995-96 season, the typical variety of video games performed by top-flight sides has by no means gone above 50.

Nevertheless, one other space of the schedule is inflicting issues. Whereas there was a drop within the variety of video games every membership facet is enjoying, the worldwide soccer calendar is busier than ever.

In every decade because the Nineteen Sixties, the variety of video games England, France, Germany, Spain, Italy and the Netherlands have performed on common every year has steadily elevated. Within the instances of Spain and Italy, the typical variety of video games they’re enjoying every year has doubled from six to 12.

Larger (or extra bloated, relying in your viewpoint) worldwide tournaments and the introduction of the UEFA Nations League are behind this improve. The variety of groups enjoying at every World Cup and European Championship has gone up steadily over time, and is barely going to extend additional in 2026, when 48 groups will play 104 video games on the World Cup in Canada, Mexico and the USA. The 2022 event noticed 32 groups contest 64 video games.

However in addition to extra video games, there are extra significant ones, too (that’s each extra matches of better which means and matches that imply extra). The introduction of the Nations League ensures that worldwide groups are enjoying aggressive fixtures at each doable break within the home schedule. These video games are additionally, because of the approach the competitors is designed, prone to be towards groups of comparable high quality.

It’s due to this fact tougher than ever for nationwide group managers to depart the very best gamers out or permit them a relaxation, or to rotate their squad. Once more, it’s the finest and most indispensable gamers who’re pushed to play essentially the most.

It’s clear, then, that this is a matter with a pinch level on the prime of the sport. Not each top-flight membership has a calendar with European fixtures and cup video games dotted throughout, nor do all of them have squads filled with internationals who can’t have slightly downtime when worldwide breaks or main summer season tournaments roll round.

And looking out again by means of historical past, there’s little proof that membership sides are enjoying extra matches. As a substitute, with greater matchday squads allowed and 5 substitutions now permitted, gamers are enjoying much less.

There’s no approach any supervisor within the trendy recreation – not to mention the medical workers – would countenance any of their gamers beginning all 70 of their group’s matches in a single season, like Talbot did for Arsenal 45 years in the past.

The sport is far sooner lately. Even watching clips of video games from as just lately because the 2000s, it will probably at occasions appear to be a unique sport. The tempo and depth of the sport is an important distinction by way of the workload the gamers are being subjected to, however simply how way more demanding is it?

“The depth and high quality on the prime of the sport is now so excessive that there’s simply no respite,” Neil Mason, guide physiotherapist with 25 years’ expertise in elite sport together with with Brentford and the Premier League, tells Opta Analyst.

“The extent that they’re anticipated to play at is simply relentless. Nowadays, every thing is optimised to permit the gamers to carry out on the highest doable degree their physique can handle.

“That is only a idea, however again within the Nineteen Seventies and Eighties, perhaps the gamers have been enjoying at 80% of what they have been able to. They could have thought they have been enjoying at 100%, however bodily, they weren’t capable of attain that degree. Their eating regimen, restoration, every thing simply wasn’t something like as environment friendly.

“Nowadays, every thing concerning the growth of a participant permits them to carry out at the next degree. It has improved the standard of the sport, but it surely additionally will increase the pressure on the gamers immeasurably.”

Talbot acknowledges that the game is faster and tougher in that sense, however he additionally raises one other distinction that’s value contemplating: “Issues have been totally different [when I played],” he says. “Soccer was slower, however we weren’t given any of the assistance with restoration or preparation. You have been by yourself in some ways.”

Sports activities science was non-existent earlier than the Premier League period. Balls and equipment absorbed and held rainwater and would weigh way more than they do now. Pitches have been muddy and way more tough to run on.

It’s unattainable to precisely evaluate the issue of enjoying soccer within the Nineteen Seventies with 2024, however each clearly had large – although contrasting – challenges.

Mason insists that Rodri’s damage – “traumatic” in nature – was not the results of overwork. “His was the type of freak damage you stand up and down the nation each week.”

However whereas it might not have been straight attributable to enjoying such a big quantity of soccer, just by being on the pitch greater than most different elite-level footballers, Rodri was absolutely extra prone to endure any type of damage. Given how a lot he has performed over the previous two years, it was arguably only a matter of time earlier than he was sidelined.

So, what’s the answer? How can gamers be higher protected to scale back the probability of accidents and keep the standard of the soccer on the prime of the sport?

Talking to the Athletic FC Podcast, PFA chief government Molango referred to as for a compulsory three-week break for each participant, not more than six consecutive weeks of enjoying on the weekend and in midweek, and a most of 50-60 video games per season, relying on the participant’s degree.

It appears as if, then, that if there was a selected side of all of this that we might name a breaking level, it feels prefer it is likely to be the Membership World Cup.

Its addition to the sporting calendar might be argued to be pointless; it’s a contest there may be seemingly little urge for food for, an argument supported by FIFA reportedly holding an “emergency” assembly final month to aim to garner some curiosity from broadcasters to purchase the rights to televise it. The Nations League additionally hasn’t generated the type of curiosity or pleasure that it could have been hoped to when it was launched.

So, regardless of squads and sources on the prime of the membership recreation being greater than ever, including extra competitions to the calendar most likely isn’t for the very best. It would solely be a choose group of golf equipment and gamers which can be affected, however given there may be so little need for any extra tournaments, what level is there in rising the workload of the sport’s finest gamers?

Everybody is aware of why these further competitions are created, however it’s a small group of people that stand to learn financially from them and some very elite gamers who will take the bodily toll towards their needs.

Our knowledge reveals that there isn’t extra soccer being performed than in occasions passed by, however that doesn’t imply anybody needs or wants any extra to be added to what we have already got.

Get pleasure from this? Subscribe to our soccer e-newsletter to obtain unique weekly content material. You must also observe our social accounts over on X, Instagram, TikTok and Fb.